The solution of how Blizzard can solve some of this issue is so plain simple it’s ridiculous they’ve not done it yet… and yes this idea WILL be unpopular.
Simply put, close off making new characters for new players on realms that are High or Full, and also the top 20% of the Medium realms. Only new players btw, not people creating alts on said realms.
I was on an alt a few weeks back, and this an actual comment I got from a person who was doing a boss fight with me: “I’m glad I did this boss here and not Silvermoon. There I’d have either huge lag, or would find a horde stole the tag from me…”
I asked them why they were on my main’s realm instead of Silvermoon. The player claimed they’re the GM of a large guild and they’d switch off Real ID for a few hours then “escape the chaos” on Silvermoon, saying “there you literally queue for a chance at picking up a quest item. If I could I’d convince my guild to move here…”
This is why I wonder WHY the High and Full realms are even open for new players…
You’d want a brand new player to experience the game at its best (warts and all, allow me to giggle at saying this btw as it’s not been at its best for a while). But making certain that the “new players” go to the realms where they’d get the best chance for this - like doing the quests, dungeons, boss fights with NO LAG - is in the best interest of Blizzard and the player. Also, them arriving on the lower populated realms means they’d get a revival, and if players there make such new comers welcome it gives them a chance at surviving.
Maybe the solution is as simple as… Only offer the realms with a population level that makes them bottom 60% of all realms in terms of population count. Only Blizzard knows what the true numbers of population is, so if this a weekly dynamic system (on weekly reset) and for a specific week there are SPECIFIC realms open for character creation…
Yep, this screws over the people who’d want to be on a realm with a friend, but if they’re a friend you can be on Real ID and play that way too, or the veteran player COULD make an alt with the new player on the low population realm. But you’re not much of a friend if you’re sending the new player to a realm (as per that random player I met) “has to do quests, dungeons, boss fights WITH LAG” because you didn’t tell them how busy a FULL REALM really is…
In the end there are winners and losers no matter how you twist it, but for brand new players with NO FRIENDS in this game their first experience should be a realm where they can enjoy the game, relax, have a good time, and ultimately also help heal the population level of such a realm in the long run… it’s up to the people on those realms to go out of their way to welcome in new players to keep them from moving on…