you will always find people who hate one or the other, for a fated season why not go the way of season of discovery and essentially let people pick their own tier sets and apply it to their gear instead.
people like S3 not because they like annahilator and reckless abandon, but despite of them. because big numbers are fun, odyn’s fury is fun.
people like S2 not because the tier set was in any way fun or interesting, but despite of it. because anger management is fun, and ravager is satisfying,
Truth of the matter though, is that S3 has the smoothest and most forgiving mechanics.
Season 1 is fundamentally flawed. The amount of damage Execute would need to do to become a priority button over the rotational mainstays is untenable. Even after dramatically buffing the set in Patch 10.0.5, it was still one of the weakest bonuses in the history of the game.
Season 2 is contentious - many people like it not because of the set itself, but because it used the Anger Management/Ravager build, which is a fan favorite in Mythic+. Unfortunately, the mechanics of the actual tier are lackluster and inflexible, revolving around a WeakAura to track a stacked up buff that has too many failure points to be reliable - one bad parry, boss phase, or tank taking a longer route results in your buff falling and the big payoff moment doing absolutely nothing. Not to mention having to align it with Spear of Bastion.
Season 3 is also somewhat contentious as some players simply dislike the idea of using Slam, but truth of the matter is that Slam is an extremely minor part of the rotation - used about 1/10th as much as Bloodthirst or Rampage. On the other hand, the build flows fairly smoothly, and while the damage is also centered into burst periods that can fail if you use Odyn’s Fury at an inopportune time, it isn’t a wholly one-time payout, but rather drawn out throughout the burst phase. Season 3 is also the most flexible in terms of talent choice, with the smallest gap between Spear of Bastion and Thunderous Roar (generally the biggest complaint from Fury players throughout S1-2).
Same as on the US Forums and truth is Season 3 tier set is the better option
The go to needs to be season 1. Anyone who plays warrior in 20s and above knows we need anger management to be effective, season 2 is okay but season 1 allows the best dps and less thinking and allows executive to be effective
Players do not vote season 3 as you will keep this spec mid to low tier unless blizz decide to reduce our cooldowns to 1m
I play a lot of M+, do NOT vote for season 2! Not being able to spam Bloodthrist is so bad for our survivability. If you do not understand this, you’re not a real Fury Warrior.
People might vote S3 because it’s the most powerful. Putting S1 and S2 against it in their original form is unfair. S1 might be a bit bland, S2 is definitely less of a mess to play compared to S3 with its GCD gaps, but both S1 and S2 will require a rebalance. So taking a rebalance into account S2 is my choice.
There is only way that’s S2 cause it has soul of fury u litery spam builder and send boosted spender… Which make sense ofc tint could be better but in this tier u can comppete in m+ cause with anger management and ravager pack to pack with stronger roar every single use… And if some guy here say I m m+ I wanna S3 that means he is crazy or he is just doin weekly but in competitive lvl is S3 sad… I don’t know it’s not even fun to have as biggest DMG dealing ability “builder” … Choose wisely
Season 3 is the better option you really dont need AM + Ravager to compete in m+ considering u already have a 20-25 second CD on Odyns fury, season 2 was pretty eh for m+ tbh.
