And this is where you are wrong . . .
2 Likes
Iâve not paid attention to the 150+ posts, anyone could be nice enough to provide me with a tl;dr of the whole thing? Whatâs with the metagaming?
DW I do my research before dragging people by their heels:
https://gyazo.com/77438ea3044cdb13da92f253ea1284bf
I also saw some weird as h*ck discord post about the whole ordeal.
13 Likes
People were wearing the brown cloaks IC as a show of support for Saurfang.
Perroy hears about IC, makes this proclamation IC.
People assume metagaming to stop people from wearing a (frankly) ugly cloak toy.
13 Likes
So you are doxxâing. Thankyou.
The individual in question will be spoken to about their forum conduct and language. Iâll also pass it on to his other GM.
however, meta-gaming is still afoot.
1 Like
The toy is unironically horrible you could do a better job with 200 gold and a minute on the auction house
4 Likes
Good, I will be monitoring this from inside your discord
9 Likes
The long and short of it is that IC rumours are fluttering around Saurfangâs loyalty and something to do with brown cloaks, which has made Perroy (the character in the game) report that these cloaks are supposedly infested with lice to suppress peopleâs urge to wear them. Then people got angry and said this is meta-gaming, although I donât understand how. Then an alt from another guild posted some rather tasteless comments regarding Perroyâs guilds and their members and now weâre in a back and forth. As is tradition.
7 Likes
Epic! Are we doing another mass report to defeat our foes, Red Blade Bros?!
10 Likes
Your GM already knows, he was talking to him about it in the discord log I was sent.
Given he palmed off the weird as h*ll mass reporting your guild did against us I am assuming this one will also be brushed under the carpet. Please stick to your policy as I per requested with your GM to not interact with us in the future, thank you.
13 Likes
There is no meta-gaming going on, maybe you should adress your guild about not freaking out ooc about rp in discord aswell
9 Likes
I absolutely do run what you describe as the âStygian discordâ and - given that it like 5 guilds in it, it is easily in the hundreds
You can scroll up a little bit and see how that discussion went a few days ago. You ended up dropping it and started talking about how people in Orgrimmar donât mind having fleas
Put down the growth pot and let me reiterate - canonically âbrown cloaksâ are not a symbol of the rebellion. It is never referenced as that and there is no reason to believe that
This thread is a response to a group of players deciding to use brown cloaks to represent anti-Sylvanas sentiment. My character was told as much as responded in a way that reflects his paranoid / authoritarian character. He is not himself aware of the outcome of the Saurfang situation in the Swamp of Sorrows
It is weird that a group that knew about Saurfagâs survival / rebellion from the onset of BfA is so strict 
13 Likes
Can you please specify, in your own words, what metagaming actually means?
Because right now whoever is making baseless accusations is you, seeing how other posters already clarified in this very thread that the lice propaganda posters were created based on the In-Game, In-Character actions of those who started using the brown cloak as a symbol and talk about how the Warchiefâs private parts and the Horde smells.
12 Likes
While youâre at it specify what doxxing means
9 Likes
You donât run the community. Itâs not in the hundreds. <
He never stated anything about running the RP community on this Realm nor running the community on anything but I assume youâre referring to the fact heâs put out a (freely-ignorable) public event to get some RP going which doesnât make him a leader of anything, it makes him someone willing to take initiative and create some fun RP opportunities for people. You call him out for snark yet this feels like a very snarky response. Pot meet kettle.
I donât need backing up, Iâm neither in a fight or playing rugby.
Generally in an argument if one is weighing in their opinion they want some force behind it, be that sources or witnesses or people willing to backup a statement, considering everyone is advocating against your statements Iâd say that shows something.
The attempts to distract from my point on meta-gaming by questioning my knowledge of sewing and clothing are confusing and childish.
He isnât distracting from your point merely ignoring it because by now youâve surely seen after multiple examples that gaining IC information through someone else that (might) have been metagaming isnât metagaming - also letâs clarify this right now, if you choose to side with Saurfang he tells Zekhan to go back to Orgrimmar and essentially spread the word.
Any other baseless, unproven baiting nonsense?
No?
Itâs still meta-gaming.
Calling someone out for snark only to begin insulting their critique of your arguments and voiding everything they say as âbaselessâ and âunproven baitingâ is nothing more than pot meets kettle and instead you should have came forward with a proper argument to critique any problems you mightâve had with this thread like others and you would have gotten an answer quickly, like others have.
14 Likes
Itâs obviously not metagaming if you are responding to something that has actually happened in RP and the response itself is rational and understandable.
Metagaming would be doing something along the lines of personally identifying every member of the cool Saurfang fan club and executing them for all to see.
20 Likes
It seems that the apple doesnât fall far from the tree lol.
Defiasdogs will be defiasdogs.
9 Likes
Yeah⌠I doubt reacting to something happening during RP with a RP initiative is meta-gaming? Makes no sense to me, unless Iâm missing a part of the story there.
10 Likes
Itâs also an initiative about lice lol not some crazy rebellion initiative.
11 Likes
Okiba trying to fight war in no manâs land and shot from the trenches to death.
-1947 colorized circa
6 Likes