So the moment I saw this in news, I couldn’t believe that it’s actually happening, the butchery of lore just keeps on going. But hey, Alliance players are happy and they are the loudest at cheering up of this good change, because hell, why wouldn’t they? They just got a new sick skin for Warlock Draenei’s, haha. I’d also disregard everything, if the Void Elves were a skin for Belfs, because they’d just look too good. While I do see the reasons for Void elf being a new race, cause of Alleria, I can’t see any valid point as to why Eredar can’t get same treatment and belong to the horde. Obviously, they are not a peaceful ‘people’ and it doesn’t make them automatically Horde, but at the very least it makes more sense, cause Horde tends to play more dirty. That is my interpretation of the game of course 
So while it’s clear for me that they do not belong to the alliance, I decided to make a small experiment. I asked ChatGPT what is it’s take on the matter, cause I know, it won’t be biased.
There is a race in WoW called Draenei and there are also Eredars, the Man’ari. Can you help me decide if they are the same race or not?
The Draenei and the Eredar are indeed related, but they are not the same race. The Eredar were originally a highly advanced and powerful race from the planet Argus. Three leaders stood out among the Eredar: Archimonde, Kil’jaeden, and Velen.
1. Archimonde and Kil’jaeden: These two Eredar leaders were approached by the fallen titan Sargeras, who offered them incredible power and knowledge in exchange for their loyalty. They agreed, and as a result, they became part of the Burning Legion, a malevolent force seeking to destroy all life in the universe.
2. Velen and the Draenei: Velen, the third Eredar leader, had a vision of the dark future that awaited his people under the influence of the Burning Legion. He refused to join Sargeras and the Burning Legion and, along with a group of like-minded Eredar, managed to escape from Argus aboard a magical vessel called the Exodar. This group became known as the Draenei, which means “exiled ones” in their language.
So, while both the Draenei and the Eredar share a common origin as Eredar on the planet Argus, they diverged into separate factions due to their different choices and alliances. The Eredar became the demonic Man’ari and joined the ranks of the Burning Legion, while the Draenei sought to resist the Legion’s corruption and embraced the path of the Light and the Naaru.
It’s important to note that the Draenei are a playable Alliance race in World of Warcraft, whereas the Man’ari are powerful demonic beings primarily seen as antagonists throughout the game’s lore.
Cool, thanks. If I were to ask your hypothetical question of whom do you think Eredar’s should join, would it be the alliance or the horde?
As an AI language model, I don’t have personal opinions or preferences. However, I can provide some insight into the lore-related reasons that could influence the decision of which faction the Eredar might join if they were to become a playable race in World of Warcraft.
1. Alliance: Given that the Draenei, who are closely related to the Eredar, are already part of the Alliance, the Eredar might find a sense of kinship and shared history with the Alliance. The Alliance values virtues such as honor, bravery, and compassion, which might resonate with the Eredar who seek redemption and wish to distance themselves from the evil deeds of their Man’ari brethren.
2. Horde: On the other hand, the Horde has historically been more open to accepting diverse races, including those that were once considered enemies. If the Eredar were to demonstrate their desire for redemption and their willingness to fight against the Burning Legion and other dark forces, the Horde might be more accepting of them, despite their dark past.
Ultimately, the decision would depend on the specific narrative direction that Blizzard Entertainment, the developers of World of Warcraft, would want to take. They would need to carefully consider the lore, the impact on gameplay balance, and the overall story they want to tell when introducing a new playable race to either faction.
As of my last update in September 2021, the Eredar were not a playable race for either faction. It’s possible that developments have occurred in the game’s lore beyond that point. I recommend checking official World of Warcraft sources for the most up-to-date information on this topic.
Blizzard did in fact add Eredar, but they are not a new race, they are only a skin option for the existing Draenei. Do you think it’s a good solution? Given the fact that Eredar are clearly not Draenei anymore?
Adding Eredar as a skin option for the existing Draenei is an interesting approach from a gameplay perspective, as it allows players to have more customization options for their characters. Players who have a fondness for the Eredar lore or prefer the appearance of Eredar over the traditional Draenei might appreciate this addition.
On the other hand, from a lore perspective, it can be a bit controversial. The Eredar and the Draenei are distinct factions with different histories and allegiances. The Eredar are associated with the Burning Legion and demonic powers, while the Draenei have fought against the Burning Legion and aligned themselves with the Alliance.
By offering the Eredar skin option for the Draenei, it blurs the lines between the two races and might lead to some inconsistencies in role-playing or storytelling aspects. It may not sit well with players who value the lore and immersion of the game. Some players might prefer more distinct races with unique starting zones, racial abilities, and deeper lore backgrounds.
Ultimately, whether it’s a good solution or not depends on the player’s perspective. It allows for more customization options, but it might sacrifice some of the narrative consistency and identity that comes with unique races. Game developers often have to balance gameplay choices and lore accuracy when making decisions like these, and player feedback plays a crucial role in shaping future updates and expansions.
