What is arcane tradition? 1 of the 3 main night elf groups banned the arcane to prevent the legion’s return, with support from the demi-gods and dragons (not the blues) going on their advise as they were the experts in the field.
It was night elf mages, who fought in the resistance, along with Malfurion and all who knew knowledge of such things that made that decision.
Without the practice of the arcane for spells in only this group, much of the way of life that was sustained by it would not carry on during this Vigil era. Indeed, much of the former way of life, of family life, growth and development, civilization, trade - none of those things would matter. They became hunters and guardians - for 10,000 years a while. But never forget that Elves never forget and were immortal throughout this period. Out of practice yes, not out of know-how.
They however, were constantly suffused and surrounded by the arcane energies. Their eyes glowing bright silver with the power, Moonwell littered their lands, using the arcane energies to guess what… enahnce life, plants, animals - while the priests used the waters for healing properties.
So, without use of spells, the arcane energy was still enhancing and improving their lives, as well as boosting nature. But there society would not be as enhanced as it should ahve been if they were using the magic like before
The other two night elf groups continued to use the arcane for spells, shielding themselves from watching eyes. They were imbalanced without the priesthood, but it doesn’t mean they didn’t use the arcane to enhance their lives and appearance. Indeed, the shen’dralar Highborne appearance used in game are all young faces - the 1 face (hehe?) need to recheck this to confirm. The other group, the nightborne, we know, used the arcane to even feed, which actually whiles it helped sustain them with very low food supplies, it also made them unhealthy. The arcane enahnces nature, not replaces it.
they’d be the most unhealthy looking ones… The two arcane socieites, would have a lot going for them, but they wouldn’t be as balanced or whole without the benefits brought by the priesthood and stronger nature magic.
It makes little sense only if you don’t understand the lore or haven’t cared much to think explore, learn or think about it.
Illidan was imprisoned because they thought he was an agent of the legion restoring the Well to call back the Legion. If they bleieved the Well was evil and hated it - they would not have used it to grow a tree, given their lives to defend it, nor used it to recreate smaller moonwellls all over the lands they guarded and stood watch over.
Dangerous yes, because of it’s capability to bring back the Legion not evil.
Furthermore, once the Legion returns, a ban on both magic and the need for a vigil will totally end. It actaully would make no sense to stay away from arcane magic, and continually begrudge your highborne kin for so long when they have overcome too and you both need each other.
hence why
- Night elven priests and druids are wielding arcane starfalls, shards, moonfire, starsurge, starfire etc and other such spells for waracraft 3 onwards
- Have 0 problems with arcane using humans they ally with nor with arcane using Draenei they become good friends with
- in fact initially the problem with the Shen’dralar is not that they use magic or arcane magic, but rather anger at the role of the caste in the WotA bubbling up. a discontentment that was easily overcome, until Maiev stirred up problems but on discovery of her propaganda, it resolves (read wolfheart)
Whether nature energies or arcane energies, they have both, and it all means they should look quite healthy. Also all elves love beauty. Beauty is a huge deal for them, all their handiwork and craftsmanship, from the exquisite buildings, to clothes, and implements are beautiful. The fascination of the forest is in the beauty of nature, the night sky is this in the beauty of the stars… Their mindset lens towards knowledge, beauty and excellence.