I dont get it. Why are you trying to make pugs follow “an established” guild rules?
Maybe he pugs solo for a reason cause he doesn’t like “cooperating” with people and not with a guild?
If I am part of a guild run. I am “expected” to be part of a team. If somebody wants to play “lone wolf” style, get in-> do your thing->take your pay->get out. Then its his free choice to do so?
Looking at other comments here. While I don’t do that personally (and I rarely pug anyways). I can see why some people may be “reluctant” to actually loot the boss.
If you take this item then prepare to be “judged” by the remaining random pugs if you are indeed “worthy enough” to wield thay item.