There’s no personal loot. So how can a player ask for a loot to trade ?
In raid, you use master loot in guilds so you will not ask a player to give you a loot because the raid leader give it to a player for the best upgrade / DKP / yet another loot system who is fair.
In dungeons, you use need or greed. So if player A don’t need something, and player B (you) need, you will get it. If 4 people need it, it’s the roll system so it’s fair and automatic.
On outdoor, if you group with a PUG to do quest, if someone won something (world drop), you can’t expect them to give the loot because they are BoE so they will be sell to AH, unless they are not valuable people will not give you a BoE for free.
If you talk about chest in dungeons or outdoor with group of people, chest is /rand before they get open and if the opener doesn’t need a loot in the chest, he will trade it to someone else unless it’s very valuable like an outdoor BoE.
Re-read the thread if you think i’m the only person who was “toxic” (that started on #2).
Of course it’s better to think i’m auto-promoting myself with alt, but the reality is sometime different. The only character i used on this thread is my Eldrai and this (my main on BFA).