Pet peeves: The return (Part 5)

Just look at Outland.

2 Likes

I’ve found alot of the dragons to be pretty boring. I’m still in the process of getting into DF now so will see how it’s changed!

But previously, many of them had potential but ultimately didn’t do much for me. Chromie is one of the few exceptions as she’s been cool since day 1.

https://gyazo.com/6fd01a77ccac5fcd0b1df30bac66e90f

Oh how different everything could have been.

4 Likes

Ulduar as it’s own continent is interesting.

Yeah, I think it was in some magazine back when Warcraft 3 was in the pipework but there’s was a plot point spitballed that tauren once existed on EK but were hunted out by the human kingdoms.

Another iteration of the map; https://gyazo.com/1a78cbd0caa9b665e361bcb4d1d0d40f

2 Likes

Thanks for these maps, they will come handy!

3 Likes

There’s probably a better dump with them out there, in fact I think I know someone with a wedge of them but this is a god post with some; https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwow/comments/bqd5zw/here_are_some_early_alphaconcept_maps/

1 Like

I find it quite neat that while Kalimdor goes through several shapes and sizes, Eastern Kingdom and Northrend stays roughly the same across most of the map iterations. At least in the rough shapes.

2 Likes

The Eastern Kingdoms’ geography was mostly locked in by WC2. With Northrend, I get the impression that Metzen had a long time to brainstorm it; we get locations like Dragonblight, Drak’tharon Keep, and Gundrak on the WC3 map, despite them being completely irrelevant to the plot, and long before they appeared in Lands of Mystery and Wrath. So Northrend was a lot less nebulous than Kalimdor, which kept changing a lot until its debut in vanilla WoW. And even then, I get a feeling they kind of phoned in the south.

3 Likes

For a game world that has almost no conventional weather/biome system, it does stand out that they just went “Make everything south in this continent generic desert.”

2 Likes

Cataclysm rectified it a bit by giving us pseudo-Egyptian Uldum, which totally was there all along we pinky swear, then shot itself in the foot by tying the new zone to one of the most despised questlines in the entire game.

It’s a mess. I’ll cover it in due time.

2 Likes

Yeah absolutely - it makes sense that they stick with WC3’s for Reforged. There’s a lot to criticize Reforged over, but not for that imo.

clearly back in wc3 ‘winterspring’ was just a warm jungle with a cold water spring somewhere!!

2 Likes

Lintian, I don’t know if you’ve seen these - they’re fairly niche pages.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/World_of_Warcraft_evolution_guide
https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Warcraft_III_evolution_guide

1 Like

Yes. I don’t criticize Reforged for originally portraying Winterspring with the Ashenvale tileset, because it was portrayed that way in classic WC3. I criticize Reforged for updating it in a patch to be more WoW-lore-accurate, and then rolling back that update.

Thankfully, I took plenty of screenshots of the 1.33 version of the mission before they did this.

I have, but thank you nonetheless — they’ll be interesting for others to read!

1 Like

Here’s another map, quite different and circular;

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/411187738520322050/1184559593339224134/20231213_191613.jpg?ex=658c6a17&is=6579f517&hm=f336c634ce95f95476837ca5d5b4c795a8ac95c4f46c37636444f171daa93029&

Also damn Telaryn’s mischief for getting my TL3 taken away. I could have been POWERFUL.

Un’goro is not a desert. How dare you!

1 Like

I forgot it existed!

You forgot Jurassic Park?
Well I’m forgetting you!

1 Like

On the one hand, ‘jungle dinosaur crater’ is an incredible zone design

on the other hand, any combination of words is measurably improved by including the word dinosaur

1 Like

On that note, recently went back and rewatched the entire Jurassic Park franchise.

First one still holds up really well. 2 and 3 were not so great in hindsight, but still fun.

World has it’s moments, but also alot of weird stuff. Extinction was boring. Dominion was…I don’t know how to feel about it. Some was good, some was really strange.

1 Like