Stranded with the above poster

A death knight who may possibly lose to a regular warrior?

My days spent with you will be days of embarrassment. I may even kill you just for making us look bad.
Many things can happen, Calork isn't weak, but who knows what the conditions are on the island they are stuck on. While yes chances are Calork got a easier shot at defeating Alin then the other way around, the term of where and how they fight aren't set in stone.
In a fight where Calork is almost unarmoured, with only his fists and Alin got full body armour and weapons? Alin got the upper hand for sure there.
If they are both wearing nothing at all, nor have weapons with them?
Calork got the upper hand in that one.

Ignore me, reply to Blighthowl.
21/10/2015 12:05Posted by Blighthowl
A death knight who may possibly lose to a regular warrior?

My days spent with you will be days of embarrassment. I may even kill you just for making us look bad.


I will never seek for any friendship with an Alliance dog. I will show you how brute force and violence will turn you into my personal pet!

If you proof to be any useful as a dog, then I will keep you as my watch dog, else, I will exterminate you right away and use your body parts as a fish bait.
There'd obviously be no hope whatsoever for being diplomatic with this individual, so Saerima would simply step into whatever wilderness there is on the island and declare said wilderness to be her territory for the duration of her stay within the island. And the orc is prohibited from entering this territory on pain of death.

Based on what I've seen thus far of Daha it's safe to assume he'd end up with an arrow in his forehead within a day. Two, tops.
Try to stay friendly and work on getting away from the island. Kara would decide to gather food and scout the island while suggesting Saerima gathers supplies to make the boat itself. Then they both can work together on building the boat or a raft to get off the island.
This causes a psychological question. If my character has no memories on how he ended up on the isle, how can I be sure he remembers what he is himself?

In any case, Beringer will freeze water below his feet and be on his way. Karasana is free to tag along unless she is busy working on the boat. In which case I believe Beringer shouldn't get too close so that he doesn't freeze water around the boat!
After an attempt at determining which way is the closest landmass, Rodeldë would probably simply walk with Beringer across the ocean.

Should that not be an option... well, surely two undead beings such as Rodeldë and Beringer can preserve themselves until they find means to leave.
Stranded on an island with Rodeldë, Tethenar would be rather... cold... hilariously. He doesn't exactly view Death Knights in the best of lights, so any interactions between them would be very cold, professional, and likely very focused on getting the pair of them off the island in as speedy and efficient a way as possible.

So, yes. There would be co-operation, but mostly from a position of indifference on his part.
Roast food, using his helmet to skewer it and hold it over the fire. "Bout time this came in handy, you want Carrier Pigeon or seagull?" The Carrier pigeon might have been able to send a message to get them free, but Korakk's writing would be illegible, even if they could find something to right on and with.

(Thanks for ressing an old game, another game for me to play, Yay! \0/)

Oh the weeks at sea, we can sing songs!
He would leave Korakk with the duty of making food, while he would pray to An'she for guidance and work on devising a plan to get off the island. If there are many sturdy trees, he'd work on construcing a raft or even a small boat that would take them off the island and into the unknown. Korakk would have to make sure that the food rations are sufficient for at least few weeks of life on the open sea.
Probably compliment his finely-groomed appearance, and try to chill and come up with a solution to form a truce until the two were as far away as possible. Yet, despite Argannos' friendly attitude, he wouldn't drop his guard, just in case Eridu tried something. If all went well, the two would likely discuss philosophy of the Light.
No discussion, Daha will instantly attack him without hesitation.

After the brutal kill Daha will yell
"I will NOT spare any disgusting blue goat like you."

... Daha probably won't survive for very long after, because of the lack of resource on the lonely island.
Alin takes out his mace, doing a few testing swings in the air.

"This island only has room for either an orc, or a human."
Kill him, remove his armour, use him as a raft. He is meat so birds will come to eat him, I will eat the birds!
...
...

Or that's what part of her would want to do, but Nipsty is by nature timid and cowardly, she'd hide from him, even if he was friendly.
Lay back for a bikini sun-tan while waiting for Nipsty to gnomishly engineer a way off this Island.
*Freezing the island turning it to ski resort* Well if it won't be to Faeriel's liking then simply death gate both of them out. Wait that does work only for a death knight. Sooo creating an icy path back home?
With her fellow member of Bane, Raina might get along with the Death Knight, they could make snowmen, and igloos!
(Carimyp is too cheery for Bane, so I RP this one as someone else, even if the guild is dead)
The result will strongly depend on the night elf approach.

Being sided with the alliance, Amnastaria had fought alongside night elves before - though both sided tended to be cold and suspicious of each other. What will happen on the islands depends if the night elf could put aside her distrust - if she does, they will co-operate. If not, it will end with a cold departure, and angry Amanstaria going to another part of the island to survive on her own.

As a hunter, Amnastaria can survive in the wild for a long period, with or without the other elf. But still, she would be happy (even if she won't be quick to admit it) for some friendly company, for a change.
At the very best, it would very much be a case of them both acknowledging that the entire situation is rather dire, and that it would be in their best interests to put aside their current enmities and leave the island... after which they return to being the bitter enemies that they are.

At the worst, and perhaps more likely, one of them will take it upon themselves to dispose of the other and then try and strike out on their own.
A Pandaren lady on a very small wooden boat is fishing, she captures an elf in a net with a funny looking helmet.
"Welcome to Shenzin-su, I hope you like Pandaren food. It will be quite some time before there's another balloon to take you home!" She pulls an impaled fish off one of the.. err.. prongs. "You look funny, what are you?"

If the elf doesn't go crazy from possibly being stuck on an island with only Pandaren for the rest of his days, he will certainly go crazy at the notice that the only meat seems to be vermin and fish. The rest is vegetation!
Edit: I'm assuming the animals on the isle would be rationed, to stop them from being wiped out.