when your game mode consists of 90%+ twitch users it’s quite evident it’s inferior.
yes when you enter combat u are in the threat table, but not with prehot threat, unless u enter before they are finished ticking.
tanks clicking off either have macros from when buff cap was a thing or are assuming the healer is stupid and will enter combat before he actually needs healing
Where exactly do you take your numbers from? 90%+ streamers. I dont have numbers but from playing on a hardcore server, I think the majority of people are non streamers. Many of which are attracted by the hype generated by certain streamers though. But even if, what specifically makes a twitch streamer a worse player?
To be fair, regarding pre hotting and being out of combat. Even if you get the threat added once you enter, it leads to the tank getting some time to take threat. Even if you start with more non effective threat since you are out of combat. like he can out aggro you before you enter, kind of thing.
the streamers are not as bad as the viewers. i do also think the majority are not streamers, but the majority are twitch users.
yes. hotting is good as it effectively gives the tank a bigger health pool before he needs healing & healer to enter combat
It works just fine. You need DPS players who can wait for 5 sunders, watch threat meter and respect kill order.
In my example did I say the healer didnt enter combat, most of the time you dont stay out of combat unless you are way in the back, so fairly often the healer do enter combat decently quickly they can still drink the water they started drinking before the pull though.
Running over, aka melee mobs
I didnt talk about ranged packs I talked about the most common type of mob in vanilla dungeons melee.
If the mobs are running over to me and there are casters there im clearly losing, if there are no casters or ranged mobs there is no need to los. If the healer is not well away from me they get put into combat the second I pull anyways, not everyone plays the game perfectly and you sound like you think that everyone should be playing perfectly.
the healer is not positioning correctly or the pack is pulled back way too far. the healer should be positioned to be (close to) in range to cast heals where the next pack is tanked.
they shouldnt be at risk of entering combat unless the pack is dragged back due to a pat or something, but the tank should have plenty of aggro by then or dps should from aoe at least.
“so lets say the tank gets hit by one mob and the rest of the pack are running over”
The tank would have had plenty of time to hit the mobs in an all melee pack before anything has a chance to reach the healer.
That’s a roundabout way of saying it doesn’t work.
By the time 5 sunders would be applied the entire pack is half dead from my blizzard while skilled tank taunts the frontrunner and other 2 dps interrupt/stun/kill priority targets like casters. If there’s 2 aoe casters, the pack is dead before 5 sunders would be applied.
Even if we don’t AoE for some reason, I can comfortably “tank” 1-2 mobs with nova into ice barrier absorb for 3 hits into slow from coc/frb into nova. Generally role of a tank in modern group is hold bosses aggro and on packs taunt off healer or mage, not physically tank the hits from the pack.
You didnt see that part of my post did you? Yes in a ideal world the healer is not being pulled in but it happens fairly often, dont trust anyone you pug with to even know how to get to the dungeon let alone how to play.
ok but u are responding to my response to a healer claiming he shouldnt be hotting. ur issue is healers like him playing poorly which my response is how to play better as a healer. but yes indeed 99% of the people playing this game are bad and do not understand other roles & classes let alone their own role & class
everything you’ve said points towards it and you play tauren, female & druid. all statistics known to mankind back up my claim
That doesn’t make sense. Those are not metrics for player performance. I would love to see your statistics.
Regardless, I am not criticizing your comment on factual correctness. I am criticizing your social skills. You don’t have to be a dick while making your point.
im not teaching special ed to make friends
You forget to link your statistics. Also not being a dick is basic decency. Nothing about teaching friends or any of that nonsense that you just said. Poor social skills, that’s all.
you criticize my social skills. you seem to be assuming i dont want to be rude, but would my social skills not be adequate if i want to come off as passive aggressive?
No, because the axiom is that a decent person doesn’t want to be passive aggressive.
you are not a decent person either, just read through your own arrogant posts
you started off with complete hypocrisy, far from being diplomatic
i had no issues with that statement but further on u called me a sociopath (pirate software) when you were behaving like a narcissist yourself. you doubled down on being objectively wrong. you also just called anything a straw man when it added to the intial statement, when you yourself did the exact same thing. you argue like a woman/narcissist, complete waste of time
The packs where you need a tank to wear a shield are the places where it matters if the rogue is tanking or not. Without shield and a warrior not sitting defensive stance the mitigation is very comparable. It’s not a straw man as it is relevant to what you brought up regarding wanting a high mitigation tank. When you are talking about something like BRD it’s easier to heal a high lvl rogue than a lower lvl warrior aswell due to lack of crushing blows. Especially with the average warrior just playing arms & sitting berserker stance even with whirlwind on cd.
What proof do you expect? You need me to make a video for you to show how you don’t get aggro from hots? Play the game and find out yourself.
I haven’t equated them. Why would I have to get hurt? Complete NPC response btw
I can’t prove to you that brainrotted twitch viewers that write emotes in wow are worse, but if you continue playing the game you will notice a pattern. Some of the streamers are very good players, most probably average 10-20 iq points above their viewers.
I am very well aware that horde (the worst faction) and druid (the worst class) can only be played by tauren (the worst race), the three combined creates a legitimate bias towards your poor choices.
Women tend to argue with emotions instead of logic, a waste of time. Narcissist part was your deflection by repeatedly calling things strawmen, a waste of time.