I want to preface this with a little something abt myself:
My name is Gubc from the German Guild “Bananas in Pyjamas” on the german Realm Patchwork(transed from Lucifron) we are a fairly small semi hardcore Guild. We cleared all the Content in Classic WoW.
It pains me to say but most of Classic Vanilla content was a total Pushover except Naxxramas. On our Server wich isnt on the Top End of EU Servers the amount of Guilds that cleared MC BWL and AQ40 without much Resistance was very large infact i dont know any guild on my server that raids that hasnt cleared Aq40.
The only “real” challenge for many guilds was Naxxramas wich is still only cleared by 5(?) guilds on the Server with 4HM Saph and Kel being Roadblocks.
In my Opinion and for me personally this made Vanilla less good than it couldve been. Naxxramas and the Experience that i had with my Guild wich i found in Classic was Amazing. Even with 15yrs of Knowledge, Experienced Leader Ship, Min-Maxing with Consumes and World Buffs that Place was and is still a good Challenge. Ofc it is not on the difficulty of modern Mythic or even Heroic Raids but it doenst have to be that complex to provide a satisfying Challenge. This added greatly to the enjoyment i had in Phase 6 of classic.
If you doit like we do and you are like me who is a fairly careless person raiding Naxx suuuucks objectively you have to farm tons of consumes get world buffs get yelled at by your raidlead because you added some stinky abomination of stupid green slime but it doenst feel as shallow as killing ragnaros in phase 1 2nd ID without Sons spawning, skipping an entire phase of the bossfight.
Wich leads me to the Title of this Thread:
If we want an authentic Burning Crusade do we need Blizzard to make Changes?
Or do we want Changes in general?
With the TBC Naughty-Server Meta that was also prevalent in Classic Vanilla - I cant see Nerfed Heroics, T4,T5,T6 being a reasonable challenge for Players in 2020
What do you think about this “Issue” ?
ps: Blizz if u read this - plz give Alliance Seal of Blood